Back to Blog Page

Why Did Some Influencers Switch Brands? Matters for eCommerce

March 19, 2025

Influencers are key players in building brand trust and driving consumer behavior. When an influencer shifts their allegiance from one brand to another, it can send ripples across the industry, impacting consumer perception, sales, and engagement. But these changes also present unique opportunities for savvy Shopify store owners.

The Nature of Influencer Brand Partnerships

The relationship between influencers and brands is often not a permanent one. Influencers may change brands for a variety of reasons, including:

  • Better Compensation: As influencers grow their following, they often seek higher-paying partnerships or brands that offer more lucrative contracts.
  • Aligning with Personal Values: An influencer’s personal brand is closely tied to their public persona. If they feel more aligned with another brand’s mission or values, they may switch to reflect their evolving personal beliefs.
  • Market Trends: Influencers are constantly on the lookout for trends. Switching brands might be a strategic move to stay relevant and tap into new markets.

Why Should Shopify Store Owners Care?

When influencers switch brands, the impact on your eCommerce store can be significant. Here’s why:

  1. Loss of Social Proof: Influencers often provide the social proof that makes customers feel more confident in making purchases. If an influencer shifts to a competitor, you might lose that trust-building element.
  2. Changes in Engagement: Influencers bring with them a dedicated following. When they switch brands, the brand’s ability to maintain engagement and foster community can be disrupted.
  3. Brand Perception: An influencer’s switch can shape how consumers perceive the brand they’re moving to and the brand they’re leaving. Negative perceptions could have a damaging effect on your brand image.

But there’s another side to this: influencer switches also present opportunities for brands to capitalize on the moment and re-align their marketing strategies. By monitoring influencer shifts, Shopify store owners can position themselves to leverage the situation to their advantage.

How FamousTracker Solves This Problem

Tracking influencer movements and their impact on your brand can be difficult without the right tools. FamousTracker offers Shopify store owners the ability to closely monitor influencer campaigns, including when influencers switch brands. Here’s how FamousTracker can help:

1. Monitor Influencer Shifts in Real-Time

FamousTracker tracks the influencers who are working with your brand and monitors any shifts in their campaigns. When an influencer switches to a competitor, you’ll be notified, allowing you to react and adapt quickly. This helps you stay ahead of the curve in a competitive market.

2. Evaluate Influencer Performance

FamousTracker enables you to track the performance of each influencer in real-time. If an influencer moves to a competitor, you can assess whether their impact on your brand was significant enough to warrant new strategies or new influencer partnerships.

3. Optimize New Influencer Collaborations

When an influencer switches brands, it’s a chance to assess your current influencer network and decide whether to invest in new partnerships. FamousTracker allows you to identify top-performing influencers, optimize collaborations, and drive greater ROI for your marketing efforts.

Top Benefits of Influencer Switching Brands for eCommerce Brands

While an influencer’s switch might seem like a setback, it can actually offer several key advantages for Shopify store owners. Here’s how:

1. Opportunity for Better Brand Alignment

An influencer’s switch often signals a shift in their personal brand or values. For your Shopify store, this is an opportunity to re-evaluate your own brand alignment and find influencers who share your mission. A well-aligned partnership can result in more authentic marketing and higher engagement.

Example Benefit: A skincare brand that partners with a vegan influencer who switches to a new cruelty-free skincare line can reposition itself as more eco-conscious by choosing an influencer who aligns with these values.

2. Boosting Customer Loyalty and Engagement

If an influencer switches brands and continues to endorse your products, it could spark curiosity among their followers and generate even more engagement. Their audience might want to learn why they switched, providing an opportunity for you to capitalize on the fresh interest.

Example Benefit: When a fitness influencer switches to a competitor but continues using your activewear, their followers will take notice, boosting engagement and driving traffic to your Shopify store.

3. Increase in Market Reach

Influencers often switch brands to tap into new markets, and as they do so, they bring their audience with them. If an influencer switches to your brand, it could help you reach untapped audiences and expand your brand’s reach.

Example Benefit: If a tech influencer switches to a new smartwatch brand and promotes your brand in the process, you gain access to a whole new audience segment that may have never considered your products before.

5 Creative Ways to Leverage Influencers Switching Brands for eCommerce Growth

When influencers switch brands, it opens up numerous creative opportunities for your Shopify store. Here are five ways to make the most of it:

1. Reposition Your Brand as the Next Big Thing

If an influencer switches to a competitor, you can use this as an opportunity to highlight why your products are the better choice. Launch a marketing campaign that capitalizes on their transition and show your audience how your brand aligns better with their needs or values.

Example: A beauty brand could create a campaign around the idea of "The Best Choice for Your Skin" after an influencer switches to a competitor. This can encourage followers to reconsider their loyalty to the previous brand.

2. Initiate New Influencer Partnerships

When an influencer switches brands, there’s a potential opening to collaborate with someone new. Leverage this opportunity by identifying influencers who align with your brand values and can offer fresh content to attract new customers.

Example: After an influencer’s brand switch, a Shopify store specializing in sustainable fashion could find an influencer who shares their eco-friendly mission and collaborate on new campaigns.

3. Launch Time-Limited Offers to Capture the Shift in Audience Interest

Influencer switches often create a spike in audience interest. You can create limited-time offers to capitalize on this curiosity. Offering discounts or exclusive products for a short period could drive traffic to your store and increase conversions.

Example: A Shopify store selling electronics can offer a “welcome-back” promotion after an influencer switches back to endorsing their brand, encouraging immediate purchases.

4. Create a Social Media Challenge or Trend

Take advantage of an influencer’s transition by using it as the foundation for a new social media trend or challenge. Encourage influencers and followers to get involved, which can help generate buzz around your brand.

Example: If an influencer known for beauty tutorials switches to a new skincare brand, you can launch a "Glow Up Challenge," encouraging their followers to showcase their skin transformation using your products.

5. Leverage the Power of Retargeting Ads

After an influencer switches brands, use retargeting ads to stay top-of-mind with their audience. By targeting their followers with personalized ads, you can continue to build trust and push them closer to making a purchase.

Example: A Shopify store selling fitness apparel can use retargeting ads on Instagram to show the influencer using their gear, reminding their audience of the brand’s value.

Real-Life Case Studies or Hypothetical Scenarios

Case Study: How an Influencer Switch Boosted a Fashion Brand’s Sales

A popular fashion influencer who previously promoted a fast-fashion brand switched to promoting a sustainable fashion line. In response, a competing eco-friendly Shopify store launched a campaign highlighting its values of sustainability, featuring the influencer in the campaign. The result? A 25% increase in sales and a significant boost in brand visibility, thanks to the new influencer's audience.

Hypothetical Scenario: Shopify Store Reacts to Influencer Switch

A Shopify store selling luxury watches notices that an influencer who was previously endorsing a competitor's watch brand has switched to promoting a new tech brand. The Shopify store decides to collaborate with another influencer in the same space to promote its high-end models, using the influencer’s large, relevant following to drive engagement and sales. This move creates a fresh wave of interest and results in a 15% increase in conversions.

Conclusion + Call to Action

Did some influencers switch brands? Yes, and this shift is something Shopify store owners can learn from and leverage to boost their eCommerce marketing strategies. By staying on top of these changes, you can capitalize on the opportunity to build deeper connections with your customers and position your store for growth.

Take advantage of influencer shifts with https://apps.shopify.com/famous-tracker Track your influencer campaigns and monitor brand changes to stay ahead of the curve. Transform your marketing today!

Competitor Content to Outrank:

  • Forbes’ Guide to Influencer Marketing
  • Hootsuite’s Insights on Influencer Marketing Trends

Your Next Influencer Connection is One Tap Away

With our app, discovering influencers who love your brand has never been easier. Get real-time notifications, reach out instantly, and build authentic relationships that elevate your marketing. Download now and watch your brand’s influence grow, one connection at a time. Make every purchase a powerful opportunity

Find it on the
Shopify Store